Legal Disputes

Security camera and doorbell users advised to respect privacy laws

In a recent decision the court has upheld a harassment claim following a neighbour dispute about the use of security cameras and doorbells. The judge ruled that the ‘Ring doorbell’ which was installed in a house in Oxfordshire “unjustifiably invaded” the privacy of a neighbour.

04 Mar 2022

Team name
James Bowles

James Bowles

Background

The claimant Dr Mary Fairhurst had been invited to tour the Defendant Mr Jon Woodard’s house, during this tour Mr Woodard showed her his new security system. Dr Fairhurst claimed that she had been ‘alarmed and appalled’ to find out that the defendant had a camera fitted on his shed which sent footage to his smartphone.

Following this tour a dispute arose surrounding these cameras and Dr Fairhurst eventually moved out of her home. The judge found in her judgement that the Ring doorbell captured images of Dr Fairhurt’s house and garden and the shed camera covered almost the entirety of the Claimant’s garden.

At the time it was not possible to turn off the audio recording function of the doorbell and so the audio data collected by the cameras was found to be processed unlawfully. The Judge outlined that the audio recording function was ‘even more problematic and detrimental than video data’.

Woodard has said that he had installed the devices in good faith in an attempt to deter burglars but the judge found that this was in breach of UK data laws – both the UK Data Protection Act and UK GDPR.

Domestic Surveillance and GDPR

Amazon who designed the Ring doorbell and the cameras has urged owners of these devices to ensure that they maintain respect for their neighbour’s privacy. Since the case began there have been steps taken by Amazon and other manufacturers to increase privacy protections such as allowing users to limit the camera’s field of view and enabling users to toggle audio on and off.

The Information Commissioner’s Office has said “Lots of people use domestic CCTV and video doorbells. If you own one, you should respect people’s privacy rights and take steps to minimize intrusion to neighbours and passers-by.”

M&P Commentary

James Bowles, trainee solicitor in our Commercial department, said:

“While this case may not necessarily set a precedent it is worth noting. These camera doorbells can be used for extensive audio and video surveillance and it is important for users to ensure that they take every step to respect people’s privacy and to protect themselves from potential dispute. “

OUR CLIENTS SAY ABOUT US

Ranked highly in Romford and Brentwood for solicitor firms

Trusts and Probate
We would like to thank Anne and Manzurul for helping to make our probate application go smoothly and efficiently. We found the process very professional.
M McDermott
Wills
From start to finish our needs were handled with all due care and attention to detail.
Anonymous
Residential Property
Svetlana at Mullis & Peake recently handled our divorce transactions and house purchase, no fuss, straight forward advice, great communication and handled efficiently.
Mcdocat
Residential Property
Trusts and Probate
Excellent service and very good advice on both recent matters. Mullis & Peake have acted for our family for many years and have proved very professional on each occasion
Terry
Residential Property
Mullis & Peake dealt with both the sale and purchase for my mum's properties. Paul is professional, helpful and efficient. Explained all the processes in a timely manner. Top quali...
Jenny
Family
I've found the service I've received at Mullis and Peake to be courteous, professional and highly recommendable.
Carole
Family
Special thanks to Roisin McCorry for her professionalism, resolve, patience, and the support she provided during this very difficult time.
Richard
Dispute resolution
Extremely satisfied with service received from Mullis & Peake. I would thoroughly recommend their service as they were recommended to me.
Paul

Related News insights

Commercial Disputes, Legal, Business, Contract Disputes & Debt Recovery, Debt Recovery
Start the new tax year with better debt recovery processes
Family & Divorce, Legal, Divorce, Family law
No more blame but challenges remain for divorcing couples
Dispute Resolution, Legal, Landlord & Tenant (Residential)
Assured Shorthold Tenancies: A guide to the Section 21 Procedure
Legal, Wills & Power of Attorney, Wills
Wills validity challenges in the news